Home › History › Netiva Ben-Yehuda

Netiva Ben-Yehuda

Palmach demolition officer, 1948. Then she wrote it all down.

נתיבה בן-יהודה

Palmach, the Haganah's strike force. Demolition, topography and reconnaissance. Author of the Palmach trilogy (1981-1991).

Also known as Tiva, Netiva Ben Yehuda

Netiva Ben-Yehuda joined the Palmach at 18 and fought in 1948 as a demolition officer. In early 1948 she commanded an ambush on an Arab bus in the Galilee. Thirty years later she began writing about that war, and her three books took the shine off the Palmach's heroic story. In a 2003 interview she went further: she said she watched a Palmach intelligence officer kill eight Arab prisoners in Safed.

Born
26 July 1928, Tel Aviv, Mandate Palestine1
Died
28 February 2011, aged 821
Unit
Palmach. Trained in demolition, bomb disposal, topography and scouting. Later a training commander and on Palmach headquarters staff.12
Known for
The Palmach trilogy, and a dictionary of Hebrew slang (1972) written with fellow Palmach veteran Dahn Ben-Amotz.12
There was no distinction then.Asked whether the bus she ambushed carried civilians or fighters. Globes, 27 November 2003 (translated from Hebrew).3

1948, in her own words

  1. 1946-1947

    Joins the Palmach at 18

    Documented Trained in demolition, bomb disposal, topography and scouting. Her duties included moving ammunition, escorting convoys and training recruits.12

  2. Feb 1948

    She commands an ambush on an Arab bus

    Documented Her unit ambushes a bus of the Najjada, the Arab defence force, on its way from the Hula Valley to the Galilee. Wikipedia dates it 11 February 1948. Feldman presents it as retaliation for attacks on Jewish transport after the partition vote. In 2003 she said she lives with having killed a man from four metres away. Asked whether the passengers were civilians or fighters, she said there was no distinction then: they were all fighters.1234

  3. 1948

    Safed: eight prisoners killed during an interrogation

    Alleged In a building in Safed, a Palmach intelligence officer interrogates a group of Arab prisoners and beats them with a rifle butt when he doesn't like their answers. He keeps her in the room to write down what they say. By her account he killed eight men in front of her, and she managed to save the ninth. She says the scene is in her books under invented names. One source so far, her own interview. We'll add page references once we have the books.3

  4. 1948

    A trainee dies under her command

    Documented Her unit is caught in ground it can't defend and a trainee, Dov Milstein, is killed. Her commander refuses responsibility and she is blamed.23

  5. 1948

    A bullet ends her Olympic hopes

    Documented A serious discus prospect, she is shot in the arm, which ends her athletic career. Arabs in the area call her "the yellow devil", Feldman writes.12

  6. 1981-1991

    The Palmach trilogy

    Documented After a doctor tells her in the late 1970s she has a fatal tumour, she writes the war down. Three volumes follow over ten years. Scholars credit them with chipping away at the official story of 1948, and with exposing the sexism behind the Palmach's promise of equality.23456

  7. 2011-02-28

    Dies at 82

    Documented She died in Tel Aviv.1

The Palmach trilogy

Hebrew only. No English translation has been found. She called it neither fiction nor history: real events, some names changed.

1948 – Between Calendars

1948 – בין הספירות

Keter, Jerusalem, 1981. From the November 1947 partition vote into early 1948, including the bus ambush.42

Through the Binding Ropes

מבעד לעבותות

Domino, Jerusalem, 1985. Subtitled a novel of three months in 1948.57

When the State Broke Out

כשפרצה המדינה

Keter, Jerusalem, 1991. The first truce, June to July 1948, and the new state.6

Sources for this profile

  1. Netiva Ben-Yehuda Wikipedia · SRC-00015468
  2. Hebrew Gender and Zionist Ideology: The Palmach Trilogy of Netiva Ben Yehuda Yael S. Feldman, Prooftexts (2000) · SRC-00015465
  3. Who can handle her? (interview, in Hebrew) Globes (David Shalit) · 2003-11-27 · SRC-00015466
  4. 1948 – Between Calendars (book, in Hebrew) Netiva Ben-Yehuda (Keter, 1981) · SRC-00015462
  5. Through the Binding Ropes (book, in Hebrew) Netiva Ben-Yehuda (Domino, 1985) · SRC-00015463
  6. When the State Broke Out (book, in Hebrew) Netiva Ben-Yehuda (Keter, 1991) · SRC-00015464
  7. Review: 1948 – Between Calendars and From Behind the Bonds Simone Bitton, Journal of Palestine Studies 15:3 · Spring 1986 · SRC-00015467

Grades: Documented backed by strong or independent sources, Alleged one source or a partisan claim, Unproven claimed without support.