Home › Hannibal Directive
–Killed by Israeli fire, documented or likelyRunning count from our archive · updates as records are confirmed

Hannibal: Israeli fire on Israelis

The Israeli Military's Directive of Jewish Extermination

How many people killed on October 7 were killed by Israel? Three years on, Israel's own media, its own officers and its own former defense minister have described the Hannibal Directive being used that day. Western legacy media has barely asked the question. This page lays out what is on the record.

The directive never excluded civilians. Not a soldiers-only rule. In writing, Israel's own attorney general's office said it applies to:
…an attempted abduction of a soldier or an Israeli civilian.The attorney general's office, in a signed letter to the Association for Civil Rights in Israel, Jan 12, 2015. The State Comptroller confirmed it again in 2018: "a soldier or civilian."
Still unanswered · 3 years on
1,195Killed on Oct 7
~70Vehicles inspected near the fence
–People in our archive flagged

Part 1The directive: stop the capture, risk the captive

The directive was written to stop Israeli soldiers being taken alive, even if it meant killing them. It was never published, it exists in several versions, and for most of its life Israel's press was not allowed to report it.

Click a black bar to declassify it

Reconstruction from published reporting — not an authentic document
Censored until 2003
IDF · Northern CommandOperational order · 1986File: HANNIBAL

IDF-P-HB: Murdering our own people

Never published. Rewritten again and again. Drafted without a single legal adviser.

1982

Commanders receive oral orders to stop captures

The Bhamdoun Abduction Operation was a military operation carried out by Fatah. A Palestinian four-man squad attacked an IDF observation point, capturing the entire eight-man IDF unit without firing a single bullet and took all eight Israeli soldiers as prisoners. In exchanges, they freed 5,900 Palestinian and Lebanese prisoners. After the eight Nahal soldiers were captured in Lebanon, commanders are told by word of mouth to "do everything" to prevent another capture.

The Northern Command chief says that meant roadblocks. Soldiers testify it meant an explicit order to fire on the car.

1985

The Jibril exchange: 1,150 prisoners for three soldiers

Israel trades 1,150 prisoners for three soldiers in the Jibril exchange. Protests follow. The army decides it will not pay that price again.

1986

Fink and Alsheikh are captured in Lebanon

Hezbollah captures Yosef Fink and Rahamim Alsheikh in south Lebanon. Their bodies come home ten years later.

The army's official history of the ambush never mentions the order it produced.

1986

Northern Command writes Hannibal

Yossi Peled, Gabi Ashkenazi and Yaacov Amidror write it at Northern Command. Months earlier, Peled was the officer the chief of staff ordered to investigate the Fink and Alsheikh ambush.

…fire should be aimed at them, deliberately, in order to hit the abductors, even if this means hitting our soldiers.
–2003

The directive the military censor kept out of the press

The military censor bars the press from saying it exists. It is used anyway, in Lebanon and Gaza.

1999–2010

Hannibal's revisions: how the rules on lethal fire changed

1999: rewritten after a question in the Knesset. 2002: the words "even at the cost of harming or wounding our soldiers" are deleted and troops are told to shoot only at the tires. 2010: fire is allowed, "but not in a way likely to lead to the death of the abductee."

2011

The chief of staff says Hannibal does not authorize killing the captive

The chief of staff tells commanders the procedure does not allow killing a soldier to stop an abduction.

2014

Rafah's Black Friday: Hannibal and the Palestinian death toll

Lt. Hadar Goldin is captured. Hannibal is invoked. At least 135 to over 200 Palestinian civilians are killed.

You prefer a dead soldier and not a soldier in Hamas captivity like Shalit 2. You prefer a body.
— Israeli company commander, 2014 Gaza war
Jan 2015

The attorney general defends a directive he will not disclose

Asked by the Association for Civil Rights in Israel about using Hannibal in crowded areas, the attorney general refuses to disclose the order. It is classified. But his reply describes what it covers: an attempted abduction "of a soldier or an Israeli civilian."

It reflects an appropriate balance between the various considerations relevant to this matter.

The same letter says the events in Rafah after Hadar Goldin's capture were handed to the army's own fact-finding mechanism. "No decision has yet been made."

Jul 2015

The army's ethics-code author rejects "better a dead soldier than a kidnapped soldier"

The author of the army's own ethics code says he has seen a document showing Hannibal killed an Israeli soldier in the 2014 war. He won't say who. The army refuses to comment.

"Better a dead soldier than a kidnapped soldier" is a fundamentally mistaken statement.

Nine years later, he told Australia's ABC that soldiers had been interpreting it as an order to deliberately kill the captive:

That is legally wrong and morally wrong and ethically wrong, it's wrong on all accounts.
Feb 2016

Two soldiers get lost. Hannibal is declared at Qalandiya.

Two Israeli soldiers following Waze drive into Qalandiya refugee camp. Their car is firebombed and they split up. Contact with one is lost, and Hannibal is declared across the entire Central Command. Large forces pour in. Palestinians are killed by Israeli fire, among them Eyad Omar Sajadiya, 22, and at least ten more are wounded. Haaretz reports two dead; the army says both were armed. The missing soldier is found about an hour later.

2016–17

Hannibal is replaced by a new classified order

Chief of Staff Gadi Eisenkot orders it rewritten "because of its problematic nature," and the State Comptroller later finds that in the 2014 war the command and division versions of the order did not even match, and could be read two ways on the value of the abductee's life. In January 2017 it is replaced by a new order whose name is classified. Soldiers are briefed on it. It allows "unreasonable force" against the abductors holding a soldier, and firing into Israeli territory if the abduction heads that way.

Six years later, on October 7, that is what happened.

Reconstructed from published reporting · not the original documentPage 1 / 1
Same order, decades apart
“…in order to hit the abductors, even if this means hitting our soldiers.”
The Hannibal Directive, 1986
“In any case, everything should be done to stop the vehicle and not allow it to escape.”
The directive's later version, in force by 2014, as quoted by Maariv in 2016
“Not a single vehicle can return to Gaza.”
Gaza Division order, October 7, 2023, 11:22, as reported by Haaretz

Part 2October 7: the orders to stop the return to Gaza

Every earlier use was about stopping one soldier being taken. On October 7 the order went out across the Gaza Division while dozens of vehicles carrying soldiers and civilians headed for the fence. And it was not given once. It went out again and again through the day: at 07:18 and 07:41 at Erez, then at 11:22 to the whole division, "not a single vehicle" back to Gaza.

Tap each time to see when the Hannibal Directive was given, and where it was used, that day
Time not yet pinned
  1. 07:18

    Gaza Division orders "Hannibal at Erez"

    An observation post reports someone kidnapped at the Erez crossing next to the liaison office. Division headquarters orders "Hannibal at Erez" and dispatches a Zik, an armed drone.

  2. 07:41

    Many more sites

    A second Hannibal order at Erez: an assault on the crossing and the base "just so that no more soldiers would be taken." Haaretz, citing a senior army source (the army did not deny it), reports the procedure was used at many locations Hamas had broken into, including the Re'im base, home of the Gaza Division's headquarters, and the Nahal Oz outpost where the female observers were stationed.

  3. Morning

    Inside police command: calls for artillery and a camera ordered off

    Police national command center, October 7. Channel 12 footage; the subtitled copy was shared on X in July 2026, and the original broadcast hasn't been identified. A senior officer wants artillery on the Gaza border and complains the army hasn't even got helicopters up. Then Itamar Ben-Gvir walks in, sees the camera and orders the filming stopped. The clip has no time stamp.

    The video below is a separate i24NEWS clip from the same room that morning. The meeting began at 8:30. Around 10:00, with no special forces left, Commissioner Kobi Shabtai told officers to surround attackers reaching Be'er Sheva and "choke them with gas" (tear gas).

  4. ~10:30

    Report: aircraft fired on movement near the border

    By around 10:30 a.m., according to the Jerusalem Post, the Air Force is firing on anything moving near the border, including vehicles that may hold Captives and civilians on the ground. The IDF's own probes later conceded that forces invoked the Hannibal Directive that day, and counted roughly 945 helicopter attacks and 11,000 instances of helicopter fire.

    The Gaza Division's own officers later described the plan: keep aircraft out of the communities, because "it's so hard to know which are our forces, and which are the enemy," and send the helicopters and Zik drones to the breaches in the fence, the same gaps every vehicle carrying Captives had to pass through.

    Anything that could fire, fired.Gaza Division artillery commander, to Ynet, Nov 2023
  5. 11:22

    The order: "Not a single vehicle can return to Gaza"

    An order goes out across the Gaza Division network that, Haaretz reports, was "understood by everyone." By then everyone knew those vehicles could be carrying Captives.

    There was no case in which a vehicle carrying kidnapped people was knowingly attacked, but you couldn't really know if there were any such people in a vehicle.Southern Command source to Haaretz
  6. 11:30

    Efrat Katz: the army says helicopter fire likely killed her

    Kibbutz Nir Oz. Eight minutes after the "not a single vehicle" order, an Air Force helicopter opens fire on a car carrying Hamas fighters toward Gaza. The army later found, from eyewitnesses, the helicopter's own video and surveillance footage, that the car also held Captives. Efrat Katz, 68, taken from Nir Oz with her daughter and granddaughters, was killed.

    Survivor Shani Goren, taken in the same group, says they were about 150 meters from the border: everyone was wounded, and Efrat was killed on the spot. The Air Force's own probe, the army grading itself, found she was likely killed by its helicopter fire, and its chief found no fault with the crew.

  7. 17:33

    Israeli tank fire at Pessi Cohen's house, with Captives inside

    Kibbutz Be'eri. Hamas fighters are holding 14 Captives at Pessi Cohen's house, and Captive Yasmin Porat says they want to negotiate a surrender. Forces have already fired a LAW anti-tank missile at the house at 16:31, and another about six minutes later. At 17:33, with Brig. Gen. Barak Hiram's approval, a tank fires the first of four shells. At 18:34 the third bounces above the doorway and its shrapnel kills Captive Adi Dagan; the fourth hits the roof at 18:57. When troops storm the house they breach with grenades, and it catches fire. Only Yasmin Porat and Hadas Dagan survive.

    She stopped screaming

    Liel Hetzroni was 12. Yasmin Porat, already outside the house, could hear her the whole time.

    The girl did not stop screaming all those hours. She didn't stop screaming.

    Hadas Dagan, who was inside, later told Yasmin what happened next.

    Yasmin, when those two shells hit, she stopped screaming. There was silence then.Yasmin Porat, relaying Hadas Dagan, on Kan radio, Nov 15, 2023

    The army investigated itself and said the tank fire harmed no one inside. The UN Commission of Inquiry found tank fire killed some or all of the civilians in the house. The full case and the army's two versions are below ↓

  8. 17:52

    Eliyahu Orgad: killed in an exchange of fire during his abduction

    Kibbutz Kfar Aza. Troops trade fire with a car of Hamas fighters driving toward them. Only afterwards does the army find that one person in the car, Eliyahu Orgad, 72, was being taken to Gaza. He was killed in the exchange of fire.

    That comes from the army's own probe into Kfar Aza: the army grading itself. The same probe says most of the fighters killed outside the kibbutz that day were hit from the air, by drones and helicopters.

Part 3Israeli officials and officers describe what happened

Not activists. Israeli officials, officers and journalists, in Israeli media, including the people who actually killed their own.

Brig. Gen. Barak Hiram99th Division commander
99th Division commander · Oct 7, 2023

Barak Hiram: the tank order at Pessi Cohen's house

No consequences. Promoted instead.

Hiram never faced any punishment for Be'eri. Instead he got the Gaza Division in Sep 2024, and in June 2026 the army chief made him head of the IDF's Operations Division. His only known reprimand was for blowing up a university in Gaza, not for the house.

He ran the battle at Be'eri. Hamas fighters held 14 people in one house. He sent in a tank. Only two came out alive.

The talking points
  1. The order. Break in, even at the cost of civilian casualties. Hiram to the tank commander, per The New York Times
  2. He said it on TV. Three weeks later he told Channel 12 he let a tank commander fire shells into buildings. Uvda, Oct 26, 2023 (video below)
  3. The cameras caught it. Police-helicopter footage shows the tank firing on the house. Channel 12, Dec 2023 (video below)
  4. The army can't keep its story straight. Its inquiry page says the tank fire hurt no one inside. Its own probe, as reported by the Times of Israel, says shell shrapnel killed Adi Dagan.
  5. It graded its own homework. The IDF cleared Hiram. His own chief operations officer from that battle was one of the investigators.
  6. Another colonel blamed the tanks, on camera. A week after Oct 7, Col. Golan Vach, head of the IDF's National Rescue Unit, stood in front of the house and told the international press: Our tanks attacked. It couldn't have happened without the tanks. Col. Golan Vach, Oct 14, 2023, in Anadolu Agency's clip (below)He also claimed eight babies died inside. That was false: the youngest killed there was 12. Quote only what he says on the clip.
    Open on X ↗
  7. The man who fired: no regrets. Col. Nissim Hazan fired the four shells. Haaretz's headline: he has no regrets. His words: they needed to shake things up that day.
▶ Hiram in his own words: Uvda with Ilana Dayan, Channel 12, Oct 26, 2023 (Hebrew)
▶ The tank firing on the house: police-helicopter footage, Channel 12, Dec 19, 2023
See the full timeline
  1. Oct 7, 2023~17:30

    Hiram approves tank fire at the Captive standoff

    With Hamas fighters holding 14 people inside, and one fighter already surrendering with Yasmin Porat as a shield, Hiram orders the tank commander to break in. A tank fires on the house. Only two of the people held inside survive.

  2. Dec 2023

    Freed Captives tell Netanyahu they were shelled, and fired on from the air

    On 5 December 2023 Captives freed in the November truce met Netanyahu and his war cabinet. Ynet published parts of the recording. A woman freed with her children, whose husband was still held, told him the hiding place they were kept in had been shelled.

    I was in a hiding place that was shelled and we had to be smuggled out and we were wounded. That's besides the helicopter that shot at us on the way to Gaza.Freed Captive, leaked audio of the meeting, as reported by CNN, 6 Dec 2023

    Netanyahu's office would not comment. CNN did not independently verify her account, and she was not named.

  3. Oct 26, 2023

    What Hiram told Uvda about Be'eri

    Hiram sits down with Ilana Dayan on Channel 12 and says he gave a tank commander permission "to fire shells into buildings, simply to stop the terrorists." He calls Be'eri's "hostage incident" a misnomer (Uvda's narration adds that "in reality, there were no hostages at all"), and says about twenty civilians were trapped, four were saved and "all the rest were murdered in cold blood." He also claims troops found "eight children tied together and shot."

    Hiram on Uvda with Ilana Dayan, Channel 12, Oct 26, 2023 (Hebrew)
  4. Dec 19, 2023

    Police-helicopter footage shows the tank firing

    Channel 12 airs police-helicopter footage of a tank firing on Pessi Cohen's house. An officer in the helicopter can be heard saying, "Wow, there was firing!"

  5. Dec 24, 2023

    Hiram's account challenged against footage and survivor testimony

    The Electronic Intifada lays his Uvda account beside the footage and the survivors' testimony, which Porat had given to Kan radio more than ten days before his interview, and calls it false. It calls the "eight children tied together" claim atrocity propaganda.

  6. Mar 20, 2024

    Al Jazeera's finding on the assault on Pessi Cohen's house

    Al Jazeera's Investigative Unit, after reviewing seven hours of footage, found the army's claim of eight burned babies at a house in Be'eri was entirely untrue: there were no babies in the house, and the 12 civilians inside were killed by Israeli forces when they stormed it.

  7. Jan 2024

    Bereaved families demand an investigation into the tank fire

    Eight bereaved Be'eri families write to the chief of staff demanding an immediate investigation, including why Hiram ordered a tank to fire at the house.

  8. Jul 2024

    The army's investigation clears Hiram

    The IDF investigates itself and, unsurprisingly, clears Hiram, praising his decisions and claiming no civilians were harmed by the tank fire. His own chief operations officer from the battle was one of the investigators. Weeks later he apologizes to bereaved Be'eri residents.

  9. Jul 16, 2024

    "No regrets": the man who fired the shells, Col. Nissim Hazan

    Days after the probe, the reservist colonel whose tank shelled Pessi Cohen's house gives his first interview, to Haaretz, from Rafah. On Oct 7 he took over an abandoned, damaged tank near the Nova party and drove it into Be'eri. He confirms he fired four shells at the house and says he did not know there were Captives inside. Haaretz's headline sums him up: he has no regrets.

    He also says the order did not come from Hiram directly, but was relayed by the Yamam, the police counter-terror unit at the scene. He stands behind firing, says he could not have acted any other way, calls the house a minor episode, and says they needed to "shake things up" that day.

    No regrets

    Asked about the failures of Oct 7, Hazan calls what followed "a bit gratifying" and good for the army. Asked what he would say to the angry families, he says he has nothing to say to them and just wants to hug them.

Yoav GallantFormer Defense Minister
Former Defense Minister · Feb 7, 2025

Gallant confirms Hannibal was used on October 7

In his first interview after Netanyahu fired him, the man in charge of Israel's military on October 7 confirmed the Hannibal Directive was used that day. Media Lens found the admission was buried by the UK and wider Western press.

I think tactically in some places [the Hannibal Directive] [is] allowed, in others it is not, and that is a problem.Yoav Gallant to Channel 12
Gallant on Channel 12, Feb 7, 2025 (Hebrew)
Col. (res.) Nof ErezIsraeli Air Force
Air Force colonel · Nov 21, 2023

Air Force Colonel Nof Erez describes a "mass Hannibal"

On a Haaretz podcast six weeks after the attack, Israeli Air Force Col. (res.) Nof Erez said the army possibly deployed the Hannibal Directive and may have hit Captives being taken to Gaza. He described October 7 as a mass Hannibal: not one vehicle with one soldier, but dozens of vehicles carrying soldiers and civilians, fired on with no way of knowing who was inside.

Apache pilotsIsraeli Air Force, Oct 7
Apache pilots · Oct 2023

Apache pilots describe confusion over who was below

The first helicopters reached the border at 8:32 a.m. Pilots say they could not tell Hamas fighters from soldiers or civilians, fired on people crossing the fence "and also right inside the communities," and took targets by phone and WhatsApp. 28 attack helicopters emptied their ammunition that day. Some began firing around 9:00 a.m. without authorization from superiors.

Shooting at people on our territory - it's something I didn't think I'd do.Apache unit commander, Channel 12

In her book War Machine, Israeli author Merav Halperin collects dozens more pilot testimonies in the same vein.

Channel 12, "Save Us": the Apache pilots, Oct 21, 2023 (Hebrew)
Capt. Bar ZonsheinTank commander
Tank captain · 2024

Tank captain describes firing on vehicles carrying Israelis

An Israeli tank commander described firing tank shells at vehicles carrying Israeli civilians toward Gaza.

I decide that this is the right decision, that it's better to stop the abduction and that they not be taken.Capt. Bar Zonshein
Mark RegevGovernment spokesman
Government spokesman · Nov 2023

Mark Regev explains the misidentified burned bodies

Israel cut its death toll from 1,400 to about 1,200 after misidentifying burned bodies.

There [were] actually bodies that were so badly burnt, we thought they were ours. In the end, apparently they were Hamas terrorists.Mark Regev to Mehdi Hasan, MSNBC
Ronen Bergman & Yoav ZitunYedioth Ahronoth journalists
Yedioth Ahronoth · Jan 10, 2024

Bergman and Zitun report about 70 vehicles hit before reaching Gaza

The IDF ordered all combat units to carry out the Hannibal procedure without using its name: stop any return to Gaza "at all costs." Elite units inspected about 70 vehicles that never reached Gaza because a helicopter, drone or tank hit them on the way. In at least some, everyone inside was killed.

It is not clear at this stage how many of the hostages were killed as a result of the operation of this order on October the 7th.Ronen Bergman and Yoav Zitun, Yedioth Ahronoth
In some places it is allowed, in others it is not, and that is a problem.
Yoav Gallant, defense minister on October 7, to Channel 12, Feb 2025

Part 4The deaths: documented cases and unresolved attribution

Kibbutz Be'eri

Pessi Cohen's house: Captives, tank shells and unresolved deaths

Hamas fighters held 14 or 15 people at the house, in the yard and inside; 13 of them died, and only Hadas Dagan and Yasmin Porat survived. Captive Yasmin Porat said the fighters wanted to negotiate a surrender. Brig. Gen. Barak Hiram ordered the tank commander to break in (more on Hiram above). Forces fired two LAW anti-tank missiles at the house from 16:31. Then, from 17:33, a tank fired four shells; police-helicopter footage shows it firing. The army's own probe says the third, at 18:34, killed Adi Dagan with shrapnel, and the fourth hit the roof. When troops stormed the house they breached with grenades and it caught fire. Hadas Dagan says shrapnel from the second hit her husband Adi in the neck and killed him.

She stopped screaming

Liel Hetzroni was 12. Yasmin Porat, already outside the house, could hear her the whole time.

The girl did not stop screaming all those hours. She didn't stop screaming.

Hadas Dagan, who was inside, later told Yasmin what happened next.

Yasmin, when those two shells hit, she stopped screaming. There was silence then.Yasmin Porat, relaying Hadas Dagan, on Kan radio, Nov 15, 2023
Open on X ↗
…shelling houses on their occupants in order to eliminate the terrorists without knowing whether the Israelis in those buildings were alive or dead.Be'eri resident Tuval Escapa to Haaretz, Oct 20, 2023

The IDF later investigated itself and claimed no civilians were harmed by the tank fire. The UN Commission of Inquiry found tank fire killed some or all of the 13 civilians. Pessi Cohen's daughter-in-law, Sharon Cohen, rejects the IDF's findings and says autopsies were never done. Eight bereaved families demanded an immediate investigation in January 2024.

An IDF colonel blames the tanks

On Oct 14, 2023, Col. Golan Vach, head of the IDF's National Rescue Unit, showed the international press this house. On camera he blamed Israeli tanks: Our tanks attacked. It couldn't have happened without the tanks. (Anadolu Agency's clip, below.) He also told them eight babies were among the dead. No babies died here; the youngest killed, Liel Hetzroni among them, were 12.

Open on X ↗
The army contradicts itself

The army's own inquiry page says the tank fire harmed no one inside the house and only injured two people outside with shrapnel.

But the Times of Israel's report on Hiram's own account (Dec 2023) and its write-up of the same probe (Jul 2024) both say tank-shell shrapnel killed Adi Dagan. Both versions can't be true.

Channel 12: footage of the tank firing on Be'eri, Dec 19, 2023
Yasmin Porat on CNN, Oct 2023
Yasmin Porat on Kan radio, Nov 15, 2023 (Hebrew)
Kan 11 footage from the house
Suheib Abu Amar being taken from the Nova party
The police counter-terror unit's message to the fighters in the house
The warning shot at the house
Fighter commander Hassan Hamduna calls on his men to surrender
Yasmin Porat on meeting Hadas Dagan after Hadas was rescued
Video: Kan 11, "Zman Emet", via Kan's 7.10 360 memorial project (Hebrew). Full story and timeline on Kan ↗
Kibbutz Be'eri

Vivian Silver: her death is confirmed; its cause is unresolved Possible

Vivian Silver, a peace activist who drove sick Gazans to Israeli hospitals, was listed as a Captive for weeks because no body was found. In November 2023 her son said remains found in her burned-out house had been identified as hers.

Survivors of Be'eri say Israeli tanks shelled houses with Captives inside. But no source places a tank at her house, and no probe has said who killed her. This one stays possible, not proven.

Kibbutz Nir Oz · 11:30 a.m.

Efrat Katz: survivor testimony and the helicopter strike

About 150 meters from the Gaza border, an Air Force helicopter opened fire on the vehicle carrying Efrat Katz and her group of Captives toward Gaza. Even the army, investigating itself, conceded in April 2024 that its own helicopter likely killed her. Its cameras couldn't tell the Captives from the fighters inside, so the strike was treated as an attack on fighters. The Air Force chief found no fault with the crew.

Shani Goren, taken in the same group, survived. Everyone was wounded; Efrat was killed on the spot. Shani was hugging Efrat's little granddaughter, Raz.

At that moment my fear was that if the helicopter shot at us again and this time it is my back that is exposed. If he shoots again, it's me who dies.Shani Goren to Ilana Dayan, Uvda, Channel 12, Feb 15, 2024

Later she learned what the helicopter had been told.

To take everything down.The instruction to the helicopter, per the debrief, as recounted by Shani Goren to Channel 12

Efrat's daughter, Doron Katz-Asher, was on the same vehicle with her two little girls and watched her mother killed in front of them. Under Israeli fire, the safe place she longed for was Gaza.

I wanted so badly to reach Gaza, for them to take me to a safe place, in quotes, where I won't be under fire… It was even a kind of relief when we finally arrived [in Gaza] alive.Doron Katz-Asher to Channel 12, Dec 2023
Kibbutz Nahal Oz

Tomer and Dikla: the army's findings on Israeli fire

Tomer Eliaz-Arava, 17. A child. He had escaped his captors and was hiding when Israeli soldiers shot him. Even the army's own inquiry into itself conceded it was "highly likely" its troops killed him after mistaking him for a threat.

Dikla Arava, 51, his mother, was forced into a car heading for Gaza with a 15-year-old girl, Dafna Elyakim. She was killed in one of the cars carrying Captives toward Gaza, the cars Israel was firing on. The army's own inquiry found its forces had marked the car as "fleeing terrorists" and fired on it from behind, and that there is a "reasonable possibility" Israeli fire killed her.

Dafna survived and was released from captivity. She remembered it as "other terrorists" opening fire on the car, who she thought mistook it for fleeing civilians. The shooters she saw as Hamas were, by the army's own findings, most likely Israeli soldiers. From inside that car, nobody could tell who was firing. That is exactly why an order to stop every car was an order to fire on Captives.

UN Commission of Inquiry · June 2024

UN Commission: up to 14 civilians likely killed by Israeli fire

The UN commission led by Navi Pillay found "strong indications" the Hannibal Directive was used in several instances, and that up to 14 Israeli civilians, including 12-year-old twins and a 68-year-old grandmother, "were likely killed as a result of Israeli security forces fire."

Nova festival

Nova helicopter claims: reporting, denials and the UN's limits

In November 2023 Haaretz reported, citing a police source, that an army helicopter firing at Hamas fighters apparently also hit some partygoers, and that Hamas had not planned to attack the festival. The police denied it the next day, saying army activity was outside their probe. The UN Commission of Inquiry confirmed at least eight attack helicopters were operating on October 7 but could not confirm they fired on civilians or civilian cars at the festival. The viral thermal clip shared as proof was filmed elsewhere.

What is on the record is the opposite failure. At about 10:00 an Apache circled over the fighters' pickup convoy on Route 232 for about seven minutes, talking with the strike cell. Nobody raised any fear for Captives. No order to fire was given, and the convoy drove on to Be'eri.

The army grades itself twice

Reporting the April 2025 Nova probe, Channel 13 said the Air Force concluded the crew should have considered firing to disrupt the convoy. In September 2025 the army told Kan the crew "acted as required" and called Kan's report "false." Bereaved Nova parents say the footage was never shown to them at the probe briefing.

Asked under Freedom of Information for the October 7 operational debriefs, the army took six months to refuse them all as privileged. So the public gets the summaries, both versions, and not the evidence.

Full Nova timeline on its location page →

Al Jazeera investigation · Mar 2024

Al Jazeera investigates Israeli fire on October 7

An Al Jazeera investigation found the Israeli military was likely involved in "friendly fire" deaths on October 7.

Kissufim

Kissufim: the army acknowledges friendly fire

Kissufim was not just a kibbutz: an army camp, Kissufim Base, sat inside the kibbutz fence on its east side. Golani's 51st Battalion was holding it on Oct 7, and fighting raged in both the camp and the kibbutz.

Kibbutz Kissufim and Kissufim Base, Esri satellite imagery from Aug 2023, before Oct 7. Base point is approximate, placed from the army's own battle map and OpenStreetMap. Full map ↗

Even the IDF's investigation of itself over the Kissufim battle admitted tactical errors and friendly fire.

Holit → a tunnel in Rafah

Youssef and Hamza Ziyadne: bodies recovered, cause of death unresolved Likely

Youssef Ziyadne, 53, and his son Hamza, 22, Bedouin dairy workers from Rahat, were taken from Holit on October 7. In January 2025 the army recovered Youssef's body, then Hamza's remains, from a tunnel in Rafah, in an area where it had already operated. Next to them lay the bodies of their Hamas guards.

The army said the deaths were not recent; experts quoted by Walla put them about a year earlier. It said the cause was under investigation, and it has published nothing since. It still told the family Hamza was "killed in captivity by Hamas." Defence Minister Israel Katz announced both bodies recovered in a "heroic operation" before the army had confirmed Hamza's death.

Captives killed in tunnels by Israeli strikes, twice before

Jabaliya, Nov 2023: the army later said Ron Sherman, Nik Beizer and Elia Toledano were "with high probability" killed by a byproduct of its strike on a Hamas commander's tunnel. No gunshot wounds.

Khan Younis, Feb 2024: six Captives died around an Israeli strike on commanders near their tunnel. The army's probe called their deaths "highly probable" to be related to the strike. An official said the guards died from its "secondary effects," such as lack of oxygen, and the army couldn't rule out that the Captives were already dead when they were shot.

Captives and guards dead in the same spot points to one event that killed everyone: a strike, or a collapse caused by one. Al-Quds al-Arabi drew that conclusion the week they were found. But no date, exact location or cause of death has been made public, so no specific strike can be tied to their deaths. Likely, not proven.

It is not clear at this stage how many of the hostages were killed as a result of the operation of this order.
Ronen Bergman and Yoav Zitun, Yedioth Ahronoth, Jan 2024

Part 5People in this archive linked to Israeli fire

People in our records flagged as Hannibal Directive cases. Each links to their full profile.

–people flagged in our records
Loading…

Part 6Reporting Hannibal: what received coverage, what did not

The New York Times, Washington Post, CNN and BBC all passed on Gallant's admission. A few Western outlets did report pieces of it: AP on possible friendly fire at Be'eri (January 2024), ABC Australia on Sharon Cohen's autopsy findings, and The Telegraph on the UN Commission's Hannibal findings. But most major US and UK outlets never followed up, and for three years the story was carried mostly by outlets dismissed as fringe: Electronic Intifada, The Grayzone, Mondoweiss, Middle East Eye. Israeli outlets like Haaretz and Yedioth Ahronoth have since confirmed much of what they reported. When Haaretz confirmed in July 2024 that the army ordered Hannibal on October 7, a search of CNN, the New York Times, the Washington Post, the BBC, Reuters, AP, the Wall Street Journal and NBC found nothing. Only The Guardian and The Independent ran it, under headlines saying the army "may have risked civilian lives."

Media Lens documented how the UK press buried Gallant's admission.

In January 2025, when journalist Sam Husseini pressed Antony Blinken at his final State Department press conference, he was dragged out of the room.

Some of the most thorough coverage came from independent journalists, like Ben Swann's July 2024 investigation for Truth in Media.

Part 7The deaths and orders still awaiting answers

  1. How many of the 1,195 people killed on October 7 were killed by Israeli fire?
  2. Who gave each Hannibal order, and at what level was it approved?
  3. What happened to the people inside the ~70 vehicles that never reached Gaza?
  4. Why were autopsies not done in cases like Pessi Cohen's house?
  5. When will there be an independent state commission of inquiry, which many bereaved families and families of Captives are demanding?

SourcesThe documents, interviews and investigations

  • Loading…